The Gross National Debt

Tuesday, December 10, 2013

Some non-emotional discussion about abortion

.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.

Few things can stir passion as much as a discussion of abortion. Imagine, then, my surprise last week when I launched a FB discussion on it which stayed nearly 100 percent polite and involved no vicious attacks on anyone in the thread.

FULL DISCLOSURE: I do not permit attacks on people in threads on my page. You do that, yer kicked out. Applies here too. Comments welcome. Attacks on people in this thread will get you banned. A lot of attacks will result in this thread being closed to commentary.

Anyway, what happened was an insightful discussion of this issue. I have edited out the extraneous comments. With people who've known me nearly 30 years and have been closer than my blood kin, extraneous is often the order of the day. If you MUST have the whole thread, it's in my page on Dec. 7-8.

I have edited the names to their initials to indicate whom is speaking. I mostly left names alone in the comments. So, I have to point out there are 3 different people named Mary commenting below.

It kicked off with this toon and my statement: I admit to honest confusion.
PRP: The first three panels clearly show the largest fetus ever.

ME: The largest baby ever was born in Canada in 1879, according to Guinness Book of World Records. He weighed 23 lbs, 12 ounces at birth. He lived for less than 1 day.

ME: Largest to survive, according to records, 22 pounds.

PRP: Wait, if the first three panels depict babies then I am confused too.

MB: 3 babies, one fetus...no confusion at all.

ME: At what point does a fetus become a baby? I have yet to get a straight answer to that. Insults, plenty of them.

MB: well my opinion is when it is born. But I'm sure there are plenty who will have 100 variations of "but what ifs"

RBA: I'm gonna say about 22 weeks or when viable. The only time you will see someone as pregnant as the person in this post getting a "late" term abortion is when the baby has either already passed away or is brain dead. There is a great new documentary that EVERYONE should see: http://www.washingtonpost.com/.../f0b0570e-40d3-11e3-a624...
‘After Tiller’ movie review: Documentary lucidly explores late-term abortion
www.washingtonpost.com

There are only three doctors in the United States who perform "late term" abortions, by the way. Most abortions are in the first trimester.

MA: Generally, if a woman gets an abortion after the first trimester, it's because she really wanted the baby and told that it wasn't going to happen, or so many obstacles were put in her way as she tried to get a first trimester abortion that she ran out of time and wound up in the second trimester.

MA: I'm with MB. I think it becomes a baby when it is born.

RBA: I don't disagree with Mary either. I am SO concerned with many laws that have come about during the past few years trying to take the right of women to chose away. In many states, like Texas and so many others, it's down right terrifying what is happening. In North Dakota and in Texas, I think there is only one place a woman will be able to get an abortion. There is a city council woman in Washougal, Washington who has gone after a group for providing homeless women with info for Planned Parenthood (along with all of the other names of groups to help homeless pregnant women). This crazy council lady is upset because the city provides $7,500 in grant money to the group since they do so much work with the homeless and all this crazy council lady could say was, "they are giving out information that kills babies." No, they gave out the contact info for Planned Parenthood which helps homeless pregnant women have HEALTHY babies at birth if they chose to remain pregnant.

JW: I always ask a pregnant woman - "When is your fetus due to become viable?"

JW: By the way, my friends in China and India are quite supportive of aborting female babies. So I'm very careful to ask them only about the viability date of their male fetuses.

RSM: My only real comments on this poster is kind of a tangent. People are always speaking of the woman's rights when it comes to abortions. "My body, my life" etc are always bandied about but you never hear anyone speaking about the flipside of that coin. What about the Father's rights? Lets say a couple get together, get their bed on and make a future human being. IF the woman decides she doesn't want it, she has the right to have an abortion. What if the father of the child doesn't want her to do this. What if the Father wants the baby? The fetus is the product of two people, but no one ever speaks about the rights of the 2nd biological donor. If the Mother has rights then so does the Father. Just curious about people's thoughts on the matter.

MB: The odds of that happening are EXTREMELY small. If a woman decides to have an abortion, usually it's because the father doesn't want to be involved, the second most common scenario is that they decided TOGETHER that it would be best.

MA: That's one of those situations that is very difficult. If only we had incubators we could put the fetus in until it was able to go to its father. Unfortunately, that isn't the case, and until they're available, I think the person who is the incubator would get the last word on the subject.

MB: I understood the original question, I'm just saying that I don't think laws should be changed just to protect the "right" of one person out of a couple of thousand or more.

MA: Really, we probably ought to sign a contract before we have sex with someone specifying all of these things in advance. That would certainly end the "well, I thought she consented" situations. I doubt that will happen either, though.

MA: I guess you just have to be very careful who you make babies with, huh?

MB: The cold hard facts are that this boils down to a religious issue every time. You can't get around it. Everyone has a different opinion as to how this relates to the bible and murder, etc. etc. It is probably the ONLY medical issue that will ever be a religious issue, besides the whole "right to die" scenario.

RBA: The Hand Maiden's Tale.

MA: I never wanted kids. I never had any. That's fairly easy. If you want kids, then you have to involve someone else, which is a bit harder. Either you have to get a surrogate or sperm donor, or you have to be connected to someone else forever.

ME: Ehhh, no, MB. Transplants, blood transfusions, vaccinations and even surgery itself are all forbidden according to come religions. Bob Marley is a great example of a surgical proscription.
Is also not a religious issue. Concerted atheists have the same debate over abortion. Again, I thank you all for being sincere about the question. I have much to think about.

RBA:  I just think it comes down to a person's body being the ultimate right of that person to control. I would never tell a man he had to be a sperm donator and if you can trust a woman with a baby, then we should be able to trust her with the decision to make a choice with her own body that is right for her. If a man wants a choice, then he should chose a woman who wants to have a child with him. I have SO many clients who don't have parents - I sure wish all these people wanting children would want them.

MA: I think that, religious or not, abortion debates mostly center around whether or not you think human beings have a "soul" (or whatever you call what makes you you) or not, and, if so, when you think that soul (for lack of a better word) enters the physical body. I don't believe in a soul that exists separate from the body (or exists when the physical body does not).

MB: Mary I have two; one grown, one almost there. I fully respect the right to an abortion. Having children is a hell of a responsibility, one that some women or couples are not ready for, or capable of doing. I have many friends that have had abortions and I have been with them through the process. Each had their own very real reasons for doing it. Me knowing these people personally, I fully understood their reasons. It was never taken lightly, and at times a very, very painful choice to make mentally. I truelly believe that in each of those circumstances they made the right decision for them at that time.

MB: Ben I'm speaking in general terms...for most people it is a religious issue.

MA: I agree that they're a big responsibility, MB. That's why I chose not to have them. Plus I'm an introvert, and kids are house guests that never go home. If people truly wanted to lower the abortion rate, the only proven method is to provide low cost, easy to obtain, and easy to use birth control. I know anti-abortion folks like to claim that people use abortions as birth control, but that is a hell of a hard way to get birth control, and I think that they would much rather prevent the pregnancy than stop it after it begins.

RBA:  I totally agree Mary. I have a good friend who planned to have just one child and then to have surgery to have no more. she became pregnant during a period of her life that was very rough and having a child at that time may have led to suicide or just incredible depression. She made a decision to abort during the first trimester and then years later had a child when she was ready, along with surgery to have no more. That child that was ultimately born would have never been born had she taken a different route in her life. As it was, she became an awesome mother and who knows the tragedy that may have occurred had she had a child when she was extremely depressed. That's just one story, but it's very profound. The documentary Freakonomics also deals with this issue in a very profound way.

MA: Sadly, there are still people who think women don't know what they want and don't understand the consequences of their decisions. I got a lot of flack when I got my tubes tied because they were sure I would change my mind, and I didn't realize how permanent that it is. How insulting.

MA: And you're right, for most people it is entirely a religious issue, as far as I can see. I used to be a pro-lifer, you see, entirely because my religion told me that I had to be or I was condoning murder. When I dropped the religion, I realized that I had never looked at the other side of the issue. Even back when I was pro-life, though, it really upset me when others judged the ones who had abortions.

MB: I can give another example. Back around twenty years ago one friend had just left her boyfriend. He was abusive and alcoholic, he couldn't hold down a job and made it clear he did not want children. She never even told him she was pregnant. She was homeless, had no car and was making minimum wage. She knew she could not take care of a child at that point in time, she couldn't even take care of herself.She didn't want to be a burden to society. She wanted to be a mother very badly, but she wanted to wait until she could be the mother she knew she wanted to be. It was very painful for her to make that decision and she struggled with it for years.

RBA: I was in the same boat Mary and when I was 19 or 20, an ethics professor had each of us privately decide where we stood on the issue of abortion. Then, we had to write a persuasive paper for the OTHER side. This forced each of us to take a hard look at the other side. It was a great assignment and as a result, I went to the other side on that issue and never looked back.

RBA: MB, your example is very similar to some of the stories that came out in the documentary Freakonomics. In that case, they looked at Romania and the United States from the 1970's until the 1990's and the specific issue was because Romania outlawed abortion and the United States had Roe vs. Wade. What they saw was that women made the best choice when it is right for them to have a child and it primarily came down to those issues surrounding economics and a woman having a child at 30, when she is more often able to provide for them is very different from that same woman having a child when she is 18 and has very little means to provide. The children of women given a choice are FAR more likely to not grow up in poverty and many other issues that surround poverty.

MB: Other story is a couple who had 4 kids. They were both low income earners and barely getting by. They too did not want to have to ask for government assistance. They knew that one more child would be the straw that broke the camel's back. It's very easy to say you are against something till you start hearing the stories and understanding the reasons why.

RBA: The new documentary After Tiller explores many of these same issues.

MT: I actually was pro choice til I found out I was an accident. My mother was actually driven to the clinic in Jacksonville to abort me. Finding that out changed my mind. I'm just saying that it's all fine and well to make your decisions, (I believe we'll all be judged in the end....I'm not perfect.) just don't take the humanity out procedure. It's a baby, a person with potential not a potential person.

MB: I think there is humanity of both sides of the issue, you just have to see it.

MA: We don't help mothers to care for their children after they're born, so it's pretty hypocritical to insist that they have to bring them into this world. What's really annoying is when they're against birth control AND abortion. What do expect women to do? Because it's the women who are going to deal with the consequences. It's nearly impossible to make a man pay child support if he doesn't want to, and if you give custody to the man, you're a horrible mother. It should be easier to get sterilized, too, if you want it.

MA: My husband just asked who I was arguing with. I told him that we were talking about abortion, but it wasn't much of an argument, since we all seemed to agree.

MB: This is why it is so important to keep the government out of this issue. It is a personal choice, a life long choice. A life-changing choice.

MT: Yes I agree life changing.....for more than one person.

MT: Yeh, sadly though I disagree.

MA: It's interesting that many of the same people who are up in arms over Obamacare because "the government shouldn't interfere between a person and their doctor" are all for laws that come between a woman and her doctor.

MB: Mary T. obviously your mother made the decision that was right for her. Not every child can be born into a loving home. Many will be in adoption centers for years...just call your local Family and Children agency and see. Many will be born into povery and suffer. This goes on in America every day. The house behind me is 300 square feet, there are 6 people living in a building the size of a large carport. I'm happy that things worked out for you and your mother, but that doesn't mean there should be laws forcing women to have children that they cannot take care of.

MT: I've seen adoption first hand....I know it's not all rainbows and happy endings. I suppose I'll just seem biased because of the way I feel. I just think there is something to be said for the baby.

Paul Hodges According to Roe vs. Wade, one of these things is not like the other. I see a baby in three.

RBA: I've been acquainted with a young woman who committed suicide because she saw no "choices" and she was desperate. I'm sure we can always come up with that "one" story that will convince us of either side. But that's why choice is so important. My mother had a miscarriage before becoming pregnant with me, had it been that she had chosen a prior abortion, same difference I could have been born while another not. Maybe that other person would have been a better person than me? Maybe we could say too bad Hitler's mom didn't have an abortion. I don't think that the individual stories that make up each of our personal lives should dictate what others can or should do. It's a personal choice, at least up until viability (however you define that).

TC:  I see lives forever changed in all four, no matter how narrowly rhetoric chooses to define them. Who could they all have been? We will never know, because one person decided to make a decision for both lives.

MB: Tom when you can get pregnant, let me know.

TC:  That capability, or the lack of it, is irrelevant to my point. You can argue whether a fetus is a person, whether it has a soul, whether it is imbued of rights, or is human, etc. 'til you're blue, but one point is factual and medically as well as scientifically unarguable; that mass of cells is alive, same as the rest of the cells in a body, and has the potential to 'be' a human, and nothing else. Seems to me that's two lines of potential history, one of which is being decided by the other by force. Something feels basically wrong with that, IMHO.

MB: Going to go to bed now..not gonna get in a debate about whether a mass of cells have rights or not.

TC:  I'm not debating, just throwing a observation into the conversation, and I really don't care whether there is agreement or not. Not much short of a major breakthrough in science will change how I feel on this issue.

RBA: I think MA and I can ONLY imagine what was said. Glad I can't see anymore - I use to get REALLY mean but MA is helping me to be a better person on FB. lol

Every parent makes decisions for their children every day. I've had to hold my little girl, screaming and kicking, as a shoved a frozen bullet of medicine-butter up her rear end against her preferences.

If I truly believed what was best for her was for me to wring her little head off, I'd've done that too, and the same for anyone who tried to stop me.

I do not make assumptions for every other person, and I really don't want to hear a ton of statistics about it, because every case is unique. There are horrible wrongs being done on both sides of this argument, but in the end, I'm with Mary Beth: not going to debate whether a ball of cells has rights.

Heck, I don't think you guys have rights aside from what you can defend. I make my choices based on my morals, and the only thing that makes me care about your preferences is that my morals and ethics require it.

As for Tom's argument, I know a lot of grown people with the potential to be a human that the world would be better off without.

LMR: I believe that along with most things, you must decide for yourself. I could never have one, but I love people who have done so. No matter what, if it is something desired, it will be acquired, politics or not. I want to add the difference in how babies are viewed now. I read these comments and see a certain common similarities in lifestyles and thoughts. Now give a glance to the very large population of young people who see a baby as just another tally, the boys who boost how many they have by different women -the girls who brag who's baby they have. Babies and toddlers in herd of young girls at mall who see them as accessories. These kids are no longer seeing post birth children as babies, never mind while still in womb. I am certainly not advocating shipping young girls off in the night for 9 months, but the trend is now so far in other direction. Schools teeming with pregnant girls. I suggest more focus on the common prevention tools for ALL--birth control.

Thursday, December 5, 2013

Leading a person to reason...

.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
In this week's Wiregrass Farmer is a letter which I knew was going to spark much controversy. I do not post the letter here because I do not have the writer's permission. You can read it online if you have a subscription, get a printed copy of the paper or just continue to wonder what he said.

What he said is less important than what he said.

Yes, I know that doesn't make sense. Lemme 'splain.

The writer was trying to make a point about racism. In my opinion, he didn't succeed very well. Again, in my opinion he also makes some extremely sweeping statements that eliminate anything useful in his argument. He points to this website www.waronthehorizon.com as a website representing the views of "95 percent" of a group of people numbering in the millions. He is not, never has been and can never be one of those millions.

He cannot responsibly speak for those millions either. Doesn't mean he can't try.

The newspaper's FB feed has received a few comments. It has certainly not blown up. Another feed on a reader's page (which I do not link to because I do not have her permission) had a bit more commentary.

The majority of the comments said the letter should not appear in a community newspaper. The chief reason given is that the letter was offensive.

Really? How? Why? The writer was not profane. He was not obscene. He was not libelous. He agreed to have his name attached to the letter. He expressed his opinion in simple, plain language.

I really do know why it was offensive. He offered an unpopular opinion. He did it in a public forum. Ergo, people with thin skin were offended.

Lemme step on some more toes at about neck level.

Those who were offended and say such letters should not be published say that because they don't bother to think. They run strictly off emotions.

I have asked readers to suggest letters to the editor policy updates. No one has offered suggestions. If you have some ideas for me, consider these questions:

• Do you want to be fair to everyone?

• If you only publish letters you agree with, are you being fair to everyone?

• Who determines if the letter is offensive?

• What is the threshold for offending people before a letter should not be published?

• Does the Second Amendment apply only to popular opinions? Does it apply to unpopular opinions too?

• What gives you the right to tell someone he can't express his opinion in a public forum?

If you just say "I'm offended and you shouldn't publish that" then you have no right to express that kind of opinion in a public forum.

I am only applying your rule to you.

Lemme take my boot off someone's neck for a moment.

Think. When you do, you quickly realize this letter was extremely important.

If I am to NOT publish letters which may offend someone, we might as well not publish any letters to the editor. None. Zero. Zip. Zilch. Nada. I can guarantee you that any letter I publish is going to offend someone somewhere. I've seen it happen time and time and time again. An innocuous letter gets published. The next day my phone rings. The caller is incoherent with rage over the letter. It goes beyond letters too.

Sometimes, the rage goes farther.


Make sense? Nope. But people are more ruled by emotion than logic.

One of the newspaper's columnist's work was also mentioned in a comment. This comment said 90 percent of this columnist's work is racist. Again a sweeping statement that destroys any cogency in the remaining post, at least in my opinion.

In the BEST comment of the series, a reader said the columnist (and by unspoken extension the letter writer) gives people a look into the mindset of part of our community he would otherwise never get to see or understand. He appreciates that.

Brilliant.

So I ask you this: What gives you the right to restrict information and knowledge? Especially information that tells you how other people think. If you believe how other people think is not important, then you must love the federal government and absolutely everything it does.

So now, I tell you again, what he said is less important that what he said. The words on the page (what he said) are nothing when compared to the insight offered into the weltanschauung (what he said) he and other people share.

There are plenty of people who will attack and insult me, rather than honestly answer the questions I honestly pose above. Which just further proves another point: You can lead a person to reason, but you can't make him think.

I do not agree with what you have to say, but I'll defend to the death your right to say it.Voltaire

Jan. 31, 2013, I proved how far I'll go to protect your right to free speech. If you are one of those who doesn't believe I should post inflammatory letters to the editor, will you stand next to me when the bullets are flying?

Wednesday, December 4, 2013

Government, church legalizes prostitution across the world

.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
That headline is not a typo. It is not an error. It is a fact.

Stone. Cold. Solid. Fact.

Regular readers of this blog have sense enough to not call me a liar. They will keep reading to see what kinda point I am gonna make. For the new people reading, you may call me a fabricator of fantasy and say the US federal, every state and local government with that power, Canadian and other governments have not legalized prostitution nor has any church.

Wanna bet? Betcha I can out-monkey wrench you...

A formality first. There are two kinds of law under discussion here:

• Government fiat law. This is law those running government make.

• Ecclesiastic law. Law of the church.

M'kay? Monkey wrench time - Sometimes the two are the same.

Now, define prostitution. I'll help ya. Google's first result:

pros·ti·tu·tionˌ prästəˈt(y)o͞oSHən/
noun: prostitution -
1) the practice or occupation of engaging in sexual activity with someone for payment.
2) the unworthy or corrupt use of one's talents for the sake of personal or financial gain.
Synonyms. the sex trade, the sex industry, whoring, streetwalking, sex tourism; the oldest profession, hooking, hustling;

Let's stick with the first definition.

Here's the where yer gonna need some lube (heh heh) and the next monkey wrench.

Two people have sex. At some point money is exchanged.

Is this prostitution? Are you sure?

MW time. The two people are married and have sex one night. The next morning Partner A gives Partner B $20.

Prostitution?

"Baker, yer not being fair. You didn't state they were married."

Ok. They are not married, according to government law. Prostitution?

Here flies another Primate Hand Tool. What about Mormon marriages in which one man has multiple wives? Statutory law says this is illegal, but case law says statutory law can take a flying leap. The First Amendment covers that one. Under ecclesiastic law, they are married.

Posit they are not married under any law. Partner A gives Partner B money. Prostitution? Monkey wrench. What if they are living together and share the expenses of running a household?

Lean this way. I have another monkey wrench. What is "payment?" Cash? Moola? Deniro? Dead presidents? Certainly. As Grandpa called 'em, here's a Stilson Wrench. Can payment be something else? It certainly can for me. I have performed various kinds of work and received food, guns, fishing gear etc etc etc instead of money.

So define payment as "cash, goods or services received in exchange for something." That "something" can be anything, including cash, goods and services. And sex. Yes indeedy! Sex!"

Cash for sex. Simple enough.

Lemme monkey wrench you again.

Partner A and Partner B are married. This is a heterosexual marriage performed in a church by a genuine minister with the necessary state licenses properly obtained, filled out and recorded. As married as two people can get.

They make the beast with two backs. Is this prostitution?

"Baker, you are a blithering idiot. Of course not." At least some of you are thinking that. Some veteran readers are waiting for the Howler Monkey Wrench to come flying through space.

Some people get and stay married for the security and benefits a marriage provides. This can be economic (money), emotional, mental, physical or some other form of benefit and security. Whether or not these people like sex, they have sex in order to preserve the marriage. In other words, these people are exchanging sex for a "something" which can include money.

No sex, no "something."

Is this prostitution? Sex is being exchanged for money. They may be married, but the base equation remains.

What's the real difference between a person who has sex with many people for money to make a living and one person who has sex with one person for money to make a living?
Anna Nicole Smith (dead) and her equally dead husband.
Governments around the world and every church I know sanctions unions between two people for strictly economic reasons. Money is why they got married. One has it and one doesn't. No money, no marriage. Sex for money.

How many people does one person have to sleep with, in exchange for money, before that person is a prostitute? How much money must change hands?

Reality says we've already established who is and who ain't a prostitute. Now we're just negotiating a price.

Reality says prostitution is, was and will be legal. Some folks can't handle reality.

Tuesday, December 3, 2013

A conflict of rights


.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Telling you up front, as I write this piece I am the very definition of ambivalent.

Here's the issue. Here's my double-minded status:

• Does the hospital, being a Catholic operation, and its physicians have the right to conduct its (their) medical practice according to its (their) religious beliefs?

• Does a patient in an emergency situation like this, have the right to expect the best care and information from the medical providers?

Here's a monkey wrench: The Hippocratic Oath. Please click this link and read the traditional and modern versions of the oath. There's QUITE a difference. The statement "first, do no harm," is not found in either oath.

Arg. Arg. Arg. Arg. Arg.

How many doctors today actually take this oath? According to the PBS report (link above), the oath is not universal. It is nearly so and the number of docs in the US taking the oath has risen steadily over the years. Posit the doc takes the oath. We're now left with the question of "what does the oath really mean to the doctor?" That's something else I can't answer. F'dangit.

So on this specific case above I'm still fence straddling. I also have some questions which will never be answered in the media. Maybe not even in court. As this is a case of policy, it's going to court.

• Why did the woman miscarry? Was she using any substances which could cause miscarriage and harm the baby?

• Was she getting any prenatal care and from whom?

• Where's dad?

• What's the doc's opinion on abortion, et al?

• If the doc had been in a non-religious hospital, what would he have done?

• If the doc has issues with the religion-based restrictions, what's he doing working there in the first place?


I do have one thing to say about this matter. Lawyers are killing medicine. Brain surgeons in southern Nevada quit doing trauma brain surgery because they were constantly being sued. Get a bad head injury in Vegas and you're SOL unless you can be shipped over to California. I have known a number of docs who left medicine because they were sued.

It's one thing to sue someone for doing something wrong. It's entirely another case to sue because you don't like what happened. I suspect most malpractice cases are a matter of not liking what happened.

I wish there was a way to vet patients when they go into a hospital. If the patient is an attorney with a stack of malpractice suits, kick his posterior to the curb.

Here's a MAJOR issue: "Catholic hospitals account for about one in six of the country’s hospital beds and in many regions their influence is spreading as they forge alliances with non-Catholic medical groups."

And a quote from Wiki, which is footnoted: "In modern times, the Catholic Church is the largest non-government provider of health care in the world. Catholic religious have been responsible for founding and running networks of hospitals across the world where medical research continues to be advanced."

Lemme pile this on: "In 2012, the church operated 12.6% of hospitals in the USA, accounting for 15.6% of all admissions, and around 14.5% of hospital expenses (c. 98.6 billion dollars). Compared to the public system, the church provided greater financial assistance or free care to poor patients, and was a leading provider of various low-profit health services such as breast cancer screenings, nutrition programs, trauma, and care of the elderly."

Aside - if you have a problem with the Catholic church running hospitals, do not go to those hospitals.

That's a LOT of hospital beds and a LOT of free care. I'm willing to bet the lady in question was getting free care. If it's free, what right do you have to complain about it?

Which brings me to another question: What happens if the lady's lawyers win and the hospitals are forced to go against their religious precepts? More chilling, what if the Catholic church decides to shut down its hospitals if this happens?

You cannot justifiably say some other group will step in to run the hospital. Fact is hospitals are shutting down all over the place and nothing is taking their place: "It was a tragedy that stunned a small Texas town: 18-month-old Edith Gonzales, a grape lodged in her tiny throat, died in her desperate parents’ arms because the county’s only hospital and emergency room had closed for good a few months earlier."

It's quite likely lawyers were not the direct cause of the Texas hospital shutting down. May be lawyers they had nothing to do with it. The fact remains malpractice suits are on the rise and have been rising for years.

The Texas hospital closed, probably, for the same reason so many others close. Not enough money coming into keep the doors open.

My county has been without a hospital for nearly 23 years. Lack of money is why it closed. We have one doctor's clinic. Used to have two. One closed a few months ago, finances again, which I attribute to mismanagement on the part of the owning hospital's administration and not actual health care issues.

Back to the OP. The real question here is whose rights and which rights are more important. The libertarian streak in me says doctors and hospitals have a right to to have policies like those created by the Catholic church, especially if it's free. Ya don't like it, don't go there.

The practical part of me that says in emergencies you take what you get. Doctors should do their best, even if it's free.

Both sides of me say the medical malpractice lawsuit system needs serious reform. Both sides of me also say people need to take personal responsibility for their actions.
 
Beyond that, I just ain't got an answer for you.

You don't want gender equality

.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
How many of my three readers say they want true equality and parity between men and women? As in each is treated exactly the same regardless of gender.

Last night I posed this question on FB. Everyone who replied as of this column is opposed to the idea.

The ladies, especially, said they are not in favor of parity and equality. They all said they prefer to be treated better than men.

This does not surprise me.

Being a man, I know how we treat each other. The women I know would not appreciate this treatment. If a woman was treated, by a man, the same way he treats his men friends, yeah well.

Let's go ahead and dispense with the biological stuff that says men and women are not equal. Hygiene is a major issue. Women require more of it because of the menstrual cycle. Women get pregnant. Men don't. Men are stronger. The world's strongest woman cannot compete with the world's strongest man one to one. Men are faster; human-powered speed records are held by men. Men are taller, on average. And so on.

So, true parity is impossible.

"That doesn't mean we shouldn't try to treat men and women equally," someone will say.

Cognitive dissonance, rather.
Someone also needs to think a bit longer. Or, more likely, think in the first place.

Should the idea of parity be carried out everywhere possible? I point to the recent addition of women in recognized combat roles. I stress recognized 'cause I've interviewed ladies in the military who were in combat and inflicted casualties on the opposition (not enemy. Opposition). I decline to offer an opinion on this right now. I have opined in the past in this forum.

Back in the early 90s, a female reporter got a bit bent when she was in a pro sports locker room after the game and one of the players, completely nude, waggled his wedding tackle at her and suggested a romp. This created quite an uproar.

The player's action is EXACTLY what men do in locker rooms. To each other. You'll have to ask some pysch types for the possible reasons behind this, but it is what men do. You do not have to like it nor understand it. I offer no opinion on this activity.

I clearly remember at the time being irked for a different reason. I reasoned if women were allowed in men's locker rooms, male reporters should be allowed access to the women's locker rooms. I still have that opinion. Whither parity?

How many of you support this idea? I remind you that once you start carving out exceptions, then you have broken the rule. Further, if you still insist on equality and parity, when you hack those exceptions off, you grant others the right to do the exact same thing.

So here's another question for you who support gender equality. Should we house violent male and female criminals together? Should we house male and female criminals together, period?

Ah so. And so the idea of gender equality crashes into the wall of reality and disintegrates.
And here's yer dose of reality.


Friday, November 29, 2013

Never let facts get in the way

.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
..
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Probably you've heard that Melissa Bachman, a TV personality and hunter, has killed a lion in Africa. If not, you've now heard.

A good trophy for Ms. Bachman.
The first news I got of this was a screaming headline stating Bachman "killed a lion on Facebook and Twitter." I am not kidding. You might be able to imagine my amazement. Huge predator cats are now stalking in Facebook and Twitter and can be hunted there? SIGN ME UP!

Snark aside. Not really, more on the way. I just felt like saying that.

In case you wonder, I do not want to kill a lion. Just not my thang. I do want to kill a Cape Buffalo and a warthog.

Bachman killed a lion. Parts of the world are now outraged. Why? This guy and some others called Bachman a coward. You'll note all these people said this from a vehicle or another place of safety. None of them got out of the vehicle and approached a lion on foot. You can tell they've never done this because they are still alive.

Lemme just note also - when you resort to insulting the other side in a debate, you lose.

You can see repeated videos of lion hunts on YouTube. These vids do spark outrage from anti hunters. But nothing like the furor over Bachman. Why the outrage? I really do not know. Baffled, I am. Why aren't all these people raising hell about all the other lion hunting? Aside from complaining, what are they doing to protect the lions and help the people who live in lion territory?

Ah so.

You may be one who decries lion hunting. I then ask again what are you doing to protect these beasts? "Whenever I donate a hunting trip for the Children's Leukemia Foundation, Ronald McDonald Cancer House, all these children's charities, I offer the anti-hunters an opportunity: if you donate more to the children's charity than the hunters donate we won't go hunting." Ted Nugent. So far Ted has yet to cancel a hunt. Why?

Does hunting lions actually protect them? Some in Africa say yes. I personally find it very hard to argue with someone whose feet on are on the ground being discussed and who has far far far more knowledge about the situation than I do. "If you want to save a species, simply decide to eat it. Then it will be managed - like chickens, like turkeys, like deer, like Canadian geese." Ted Nugent.

Habitat loss. And where do YOU live?
I can't find hard numbers of the number of lions killed every year. I can state killers are hunters who pay big bucks for the privilege, natives who protect their livestock, ritual killings, each other, starvation and natural causes. Lions are killed by poisoning by ranchers, BTW. In every article I read about lions, killing and their decline, loss of habitat and human-lion conflict were mentioned every time.

Hrm.

Humans and wildlife can coexist. There's two ways to do this. 1) When the wildlife is managed per human wishes. This means killing 'em when they "get out of hand." Wildlife does not reason and cannot be reasoned with. Wildlife is interested in procreating and eating. 2) According to an unmodified natural order. I have yet to meet a human willing to live according to the wildlife's way of life. In other words, a human would have to accept an unmodified place in the food chain. Everyone who complains about lion hunters is hereby cordially invited to live with wild lions on the lions' terms. There won't be enough left of you to bury. You're lunch.

There is no third option. Ideas like birth control, sterilization and so forth are part of Option 1 and when it does not work, the guns and bows and poison come out.

In another thing I don't understand, the anti hunting crowd is threatening to kill the hunters. Anti's have on several occasions threatened to kill me. I am not kidding. This is bizarre. The anti's are opposed to killing and yet are threatening to kill? Further, they generally have little to no idea how to use weapons and they claim to want to tangle with people who know how to kill. Huhn? Color me confused. Meantime, if you're one of this crowd, tell me when and where you'd like to meet to settle this.

Some facts, which I am SURE the haters will not let get in the way:

Lions kill people. I am not complaining. Merely stating facts. Lions eat meat. While the Bible says the Lion will lay down with the Lamb, getting the big cats to eat grass and survive on it ain't gonna happen short of a miracle. While big cats occasionally "adopt" a prey animal, they do eat it within a few days.

You can buy lion meat. Purty 'spensive, but hey, you can do it. I'd eat it. If you eat meat and you object to this, I must ask why.

If you want to save a species, simply decide to eat it. Then it will be managed - like chickens, like turkeys, like deer, like Canadian geese.
Read more at http://www.brainyquote.com/quotes/quotes/t/tednugent189511.html#G9JJORbvAbre3jK5.99
Lion hunts ain't cheap. A lion like Bachman killed is gonna run more than $20,000. This website lists ONLY the cost of the hunt package. It does not list the tips you are expected to pay and other fees not included. The lion feeds local villagers who also get to partake of the license fees and earn tips for helping with the hunt. Photo safaris run less than $2,000 per person. I'll also betcha the guide on these trips packs a gun just in case. And, I have yet to see anyone on a photo safari get within 30 yards on foot of a wild lion. It's dangerous.

You can say a lion can be photographed over and over again, generating fees each time while a lion kill results in a one-time payment. Yup. I again point you to the lion poisoning, livestock protection killing and ritual killings. No fees are generated by this and a lion is still dead. As long as Africa's population grows, lions are going to be in increasing conflict with humans. See Options 1 and 2 above.

The simple truth is when human and wildlife collide, wildlife dies.

Sunday, November 17, 2013

Some after a deer hunt ramblins

.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Feel free to skip this as you won't miss much. But every time I say that, people say the post is truly amazing. Oy.

Yet another post I made on FB got me to thinking several thinks at once. Not things, thinks. So in no particular order:

Before you decide to run off at the mouth or keyboard about someone and what they did, why doncha try to understand why they did it? By you, I mean everybody. You, me, the guy hiding in the bushes outside your bedroom window, the clown in the closet, the crackhead presently laying unconscious in the ditch at the railroad track across the road.

Item the first: In my bidnez, I hear a substantial amount of complaining about how much people pay in taxes. At a meeting some years ago a local gent proceeded to rip the County Commissioners apart because his taxes were too high, he couldn't get his dirt road scraped, there were too many deputies and he never saw a deputy patrolling and so on.

This went beyond cognitive dissonance. When I attempted to asked him what all he meant, he quickly cut me off and told me "I know what you're going to say." I was only slightly amazed at his precognitive capabilities. I've found that when I show up, everyone within hearing distance is an immediate expert on me and can predict the future. Everyone but me knows what I'm going to do and say and everyone knows where I'm going.

I interrupted his interruption and asked him what he knew about the County budget. Aside from his taxes being too high and he couldn't get the services he felt he deserved, he knew nothing. Furthermore, by his express stated opinion he did not want to know.

That's a special kind of stupid.

Item the second: What makes you an expert on someone else? (See above definition of you). A good example: I have no idea what it's like to give birth to a child from a pain perspective. Or do I? I have far too much experience with what kidney stone pain is like. The nurse who took care of me when I had my first kidney stone said she'd had both kinds of pain. She said it was exactly the same. Kidney stones were worse. Labor pain came and went but the kidney stone pain hung around.

I can't experience labor pains, for which I am glad.

There are many many many many many (add many until you feel there's enough) things you cannot experience and will not experience. So what makes you an expert on them? There is no difference, in my mind, to an ill-informed opinion and stupidity.

Item the third: Our folks in public safety catch all kinds of hell when something goes wrong. Some of 'em catch hell when things go right. Firefighters are routinely complained at because "they used too much water to put the fire out and now everything is ruined." Ahhhh, what? You'd rather have fire damage than water damage?

The great majority in folks in law enforcement are there because they want to help. Yes, there are a few screwups who give the rest a bad name. But think about your own profession. Do you want to be judged based on what a few idiots have done in the same job you have? Idiots abound and can be found everywhere.

Item the fourth: I need to kill a deer. I am not kidding.

Item the fifth: If something is so wrong, what are you doing to change it? I suggest that if you are not resisting or attempting to change things with all your abilities and might, then you are complicit in the wrongness continuing. Put up or shut up, in other words.

Item the sixth: I do not support any of the current wars the United States is engaged in: Korea, Pakistan, Afghanistan, Iraq, various S. American countries etc etc. I no longer know how many wars the US is currently fighting. In case you wonder, if we have US troops in a country and they are shooting other people, that's my definition of war. The US has been at war my entire life.

I do not support the wars. I do support the troops. You may see this as a disconnect. Refer back to point 2. I also say bring all our troops home. This does not need Congressional approval. Bring 'em home. Blow up everything that can't be brought home or loaded on a plane with 24 hours.

I do not believe that the wars on most of these fronts is necessary for the security of the United States. However, I then refer myself back to point 1. To wit: Those in leadership positions may have information I am not privy to. However, as our elected leaders I also believe they have a responsibility to share this information with us to convince us of the need for military intervention.

They have not. They will not. I must therefore conclude there is not legitimate reason for these wars.

Item the last: As posted on my FB feed just a bit ago by Wyatt's mom: "You must have made quite an impression on Wyatt the other day. He just ran through the living room randomly and yelled, "Ben Baker! Ben Baker! Ben Baker!" Kids are crazy."

Nope. My plan to take over the world by creating minions in the new generation is proceeding apace.
Wyatt is 3, I think. I thought y'all needed to know how I am influencing the next generation.

Conclusion: I really believe that if we take the time to understand each other, this world will be a much better place.

Of opinions, fact and people who read 'em

.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Just like every other newspaper in the world, the paper I work for is roundly damned by the people who live in this community.

Robert Williams, publisher of The Blackshear Times, has this to say about newspaper and its critics: Loved by many, cussed by some, read by all.

Truth. Every newspaper I have ever worked for and every newspaper editor I have ever talked to reports the same thing. The local people claim to despise the paper, while praising papers in other communities.

Kinda like Congress except in reverse. YOUR congressman is doing a pretty good job but the rest of those bastards need to be replaced. Newspapers are a definite case of "the grass over yonder is greener."

In case you wonder, the newspaper I work maintained its reader base subscribers in the time I have been here, if you consider the population decline which has also hit my community. In other words, our population is down more than 2,000 since I came here. Sales have stayed nearly steady.
With this in mind, I recently made this post to FB:  
 
It was recently pointed out to me that some people do not read the newspaper I work for because they do not like "arrogant opinions."

Thank you. I can mark you off the list of people I need to offend.

It is extremely easy to offend someone by insulting them. I do not do this. It is far harder to offend someone by telling the truth and standing up for your own convictions.

If the truth hurts, yer living wrong.
My friends and followers, whom I treasure, had this to say:

Mike: Arrogant opinions? Would the phrase be defined as, "any opinion other than the one you have at that moment?"
 
To which I replied: Rather, "any information that is not exactly the same as the opinion you have at the moment."
 
Vicki: If they don't read because of an opinion, they are just missing out on everything else in there.
 
Maggie: Although I appreciate the full intent of your maxim, "If the truth hurts, yer living wrong," it hints at Absolutism. It is not possible for people to live "perfectly." For example: people who are essentially "green" quite likely do not have the wherewithal to live fully green and live in today's modernity. (Not saying it is not do-able; just saying it means a radical 'fully off the grid' move). 
 
Howard: "... still a man hears what he wants to hear and disregards the rest..." Paul Simon
 
Lori: I submit that if a person spends his life putting his opinion in a town paper every week, a blog, various social mediums and in printed books, chances are there's a smidgen of arrogance. Would there not have to be? The confidence it takes to do the before mentioned activities would often be met with backlash that would drive a person to cross to arrogance now and then. The problem is that most people confuse confidence with arrogance and see a great deal more of it than there is.
 
Maggie (again): And if we spend our lives concerned with offending others we don't accomplish as much as we might wish. 
 
Lori (again): The greatest consolation is that those who are offended by all they do not agree with appear to be the dang unhappiest people in general. The world in general will not get in step with their beliefs and this bothers them to no end.
 
Rebel: Thank god I am never guilty of arrogant opinions! Was that thunder?
 
Maggie (again): Yes. But it keeps them occupied.

Thursday, November 14, 2013

So tell me what you want, what you really really want





.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
http://www.rolereboot.org/culture-and-politics/details/2013-11-how-locker-room-behavior-hurts-us-all


Normally this is the kinda thing I'd leave to Merle, but I'm tackling this one.

To start with the author starts out with a rant on football players, pro players at that. She then leaps into a completely different discussion, which is exactly the same thing I do in too many of my blogs.

To follow the path she's laid down:

1) This is PRO football. To pull a quote from her article, "This is a game of high testosterone, with men hammering their bodies on a daily basis. You are taught to be an aggressive person, and you typically do not make it to the NFL if you are a passive person. There are a few, but it’s very hard. Playing football is a man’s job, and if there’s any weak link, it gets weeded out. It’s the leaders’ job on the team to take care of it."

Unlike the article's author, I do not believe, for an instant, that what happened to the football player who quit was an attempt to weed him out. It was nothing more than what very strong men, amped on testosterone and so on do to each other. Weeding out happens on the field and is done by the coach, not the locker room.

What the player who quit heard is exactly what'd he'd hear on the field from opposing players. Yes. It is. It's called psychology.

I give you an excerpt from my all time favorite movie, M*A*S*H:

Cpl. Judson: Bastard, 88, called me a coon.
Spearchucker: Called you a what?
Cpl. Judson: Coon.
Spearchucker: OK, that's an old pro trick, to get you thrown out of the ball game.
Cpl. Judson: Well...
Spearchucker: Why don't you do the same thing to him?
Cpl. Judson: What, call him a coon?

The statements hurled at Jonathan Martin are exactly what I'd expect to hear in pro football.

Some may believe you can have a quality football team without this kind of activity. Sure. Just ask former UGA Head Coach Ray Goff about the light-handed approach to football and football players. Goff was fired. When my own late sainted grandmother said of Goff,  "He's just not mean enough" then you know something was off. Still don't believe me? Ask Steve Spurrier what it takes to be a successful football coach and player.
Suit up or shut up.

Some people will still say it doesn't have to be this way. How many of them played pro football? How many played football at all? In case you wonder, I played football in school, one year. I played what amounted to rugby a lot longer.

"It still doesn't have to be that way."

Play football and come back and talk to me.

Furthermore, show me ANY professional activity with the same team esprit de corps and the same amount of violence and I'll show you the exact same activities taking place.

Next point. The author's true colors come shining clear with this statement: "In a society largely controlled by property-owning, land-stealing, vote-wielding, and law-making white men, we’ve shaped our culture to revere brutal and subjugating behavior, especially when it comes from white guys." Whew. I wish she wouldn't hold back.

She then goes on to make some almost logical points. I'ma use this sentence by way of example: "Or politicians who visit strip joints on fundraising outings, use profanity and name-calling when dealing with female co-workers (including the First Lady), and even our own President who only invites men to chummy pick-up basketball games at the White House."
GASP! Women do go to strip clubs.

Point 1: Why don't women visit strip joints? Sure they do, but in less numbers than men. Why? Furthermore, what's wrong with going to a strip club? I'm sure she has answers, all of which are man-bashing. I wonder what she had to say about Georgia's major embarrassment, Cynthia McKinney.

Point 2 and 3: Make up your FREEKING MIND! Men use profanity and name-calling when dealing with each other! It's WHAT WE DO! If you want to be treated equally, GET USED TO THE IDEA Of BEING CALLED NAMES! It's been going on for millennia. If you don't want equal treatment, then do not bitch about being treated unequally. Of course the president only invites men to the basketball court. Can you imagine what would be said if he popped a woman in the boob on the court? Egad. The press busts (heehee) a guy in the chest and the guy grins and gets payback a bit later.

Make up your mind. Men, real men and responsible men, will treat women the way women ask to be treated. As soon as the women figure it out. Which is no doubt going to be called a sexist remark. G'head. I'm not the one who says "Nothing" when someone asks me, "What's wrong?"

GAAAAAAAAAAH!

Next quote: "Men, in every profession, should be expected to operate off of more than emotions and instincts. They should be expected to be professionals." Professionals. Ms. White is a college journalism instructor who wrote "But I’m over this “boys will be boys” shit." That appears at the lead sentence in the very paragraph in which she demands men be professional.

Play football. Then talk to me. And then when yer at it, apply the same code of standard to yerself Khadijah Costley White. Yassee the very things she accuses men of doing, she does in her profanity-sprinkled tirade lambasting the XY chromosome crowd.

Parity does not live in Ms. White's column.

'Nother quote: "America’s history is built on the destruction and exploitation of others." Lemme let a grand idiot, Axl Rose reply:
"Welcome to the jungle, we got fun 'n' games
We got everything you want, honey we know the names
We are the people that you find, whatever you may need
If you got the money, honey we got your disease."

Here's where she and I do agree. Neither of likes a society ruled by powerful amoral types. "I believe that you can win a football game without being racist, sexist, and homophobic." She and I also agree. But you can't win football games without having enough attitude to be a winner on the field. Ask any pro football coach who has won the Super Bowl.

But we have a fundamental disagreement that cannot be resolved. She is definitely female, probably of recent African descent and a liberal. I am a male composed of so many nationalities any time war is declared on the planet. I beat myself up in a nationalistic fervor and a libertarian realist. She cannot know what it is like to be a male, nor can I know what it is like to be a female.

Unlike Ms. White, I ain't making excuses. I'm stating facts.

Unlike Ms. White, I also know what it takes to be a football player.

And probably exactly like I have done with Ms. White's article, this one will be vastly misunderstood. But WTH, I'm only professional journalist making a living at it for 28 years now. Betcha Ms. White couldn't.